Feb 28 2006
Discipline is on Child or Adult?
I really feel like giving up in disciplining Ian. Whatever effort I’ve done all gone wasted.
Since Oct ’05, I’ve been spending quite a good deal in disciplining Ian, and I was very happy with the progress. After all the ‘training’, Ian is already a good boy to my standard.
During CNY break, the whole of 10-day holidays, I enjoyed our time very much as he really behaved like an angel. No problem in eating, whining etc. He was very cooperative when we brought him out; he greeted everyone and followed instruction most of the time.
After returning to work, Ian was taken over care by MIL. Not sure was it due to the long separation or not, MIL/FIL spoilt Ian so much!
I used to praise MIL for not spoiling Ian instead helped me to discipline him. However, she is now breaking all the rules that she used to set.
After 1 week, Ian became such a monster – he ONLY whined for whatever he wanted. When he was with me alone, I still kept to the rule – if you don’t speak what you want you won’t get it. But when there was someone else (MIL), he quickly turned to the person and continued whining and stumping his feet – the person immediately gave him!!!
I couldn’t take it any more and started nagging them during the second week. I kept reminding them not to give in if Ian doesn’t say what he wants but keeps whining. So much so, that MIL/FIL/SIL got irritated with me. And the weekend DH told me off. Basically, the message I received was to keep my mouth shut unless if I want to take care of Ian full-time.
I was quite upset, so the third week, I’ve decided to keep quiet and walk away when Ian misbehaved. If I were there I’d sure want to discipline him, which ultimately telling MIL not to do this do that, and upset everyone.
But then, MIL kept coming to complain how naughty Ian is and wanted me to scold Ian. Which, I couldn’t help but to respond to her that she should not give in. You see, there is no point for me to tell Ian “Hey, please tell PoPo what you want, and not just cry, otherwise…” Otherwise, what??? Do I tell him that “…otherwise, PoPo will still give you what you want anyway, so no need to say lah!”???
In fact, I seldom scold Ian. There is a great difference in scolding and disciplining. When I disciplined him, I kept to a stern voice (not loud/high-pitch), and always keep to what I say/promise. E.g.: If I say ‘I’ll off the TV if you are too near’, I really switch it off when he doesn’t move farther. I don’t scold him, I explain to him the rules and why.
It is impossible to discipline the child, if we are not consistent in our message to him or if we lie. In the TV’s case, they want to watch the program more than Ian, and they won’t switch if off anyway! They just threatened but never action.
They all like to say that Ian bullies MIL, FIL and DH. Ya, but why? I won’t blame Ian. They are the ones who gave him the message that:
hey, you are welcomed to behave like this, I’m going to give in on anything. You want me to carry you 24 hours a day without break, no problem, and I won’t sit down when I’m carrying you as you wish, too. You want to whine, no problem. You want to pour water on the floor and play with it, no problem. You want to play with food and throw them on the floor, no problem…
Last Sat, when I complaint to DH again, he told me off, by asking me to take 1-month leave to re-discipline Ian. To me, unless I quit my job, otherwise 1 month or 2 months or 3 months make no difference. I was able to make Ian a good boy anyway, but only until CNY. After that, when he is back to MIL’s care, things turned bad.
I really feel that disciplining children is not so much of a problem. But disciplining adults is a real pain. In this case, it is the adults need to be disciplined. Sigh!
During CNY, one of the in-law’s relative even lectured me, that ‘no wonder Ian doesn’t love you, because you scold him’. This statement really annoys me. First of all, I don’t scold him. Secondly, do I need to stop disciplining Ian just because I’m afraid Ian hates me? Thirdly, I don’t think he doesn’t love me – he was glued to me most of the time. Also, I hate her saying this in front of Ian, like reminding or teaching Ian to dislike me if I discipline him. I wonder anyone else do this behind my back.
You think you are doing well to him by letting him behave like this? You are only turning him into a monster that everyone hates. I love my son so much that I don’t want him to be a monster. I love him so much that I want him to be an adorable angel. You got the message? How I wish I could tell you off like this F2F, but I’m a coward I dare not to say it out loud.





